Showing posts with label David Brooks. Show all posts
Showing posts with label David Brooks. Show all posts

Mar 6, 2019

March 6, 2019: Affection Void, Moral Cretin, Empty Shell




Donald John tRUMP has no soul. A soul requires nurturing, years basking in the sunshine of affection, held in the nest of those about you. Our Caesar Disgustus had, by all accounting, no such upbringing. Indeed, by the time he reached pubescence, his father had him shuffled off to a military academy, it is said, in order to instill some discipline into the boy. Military academies, in case you aren't aware were, in our youth, places that adults put kids who just didn't fit in, who didn't adapt, didn't behave. When a kid was sent off to one of these institutions, it was seen by the greater community that his parents had thrown up their hands and given up. But let there be no misunderstanding here: these were and are institutions. I have not been understood: Donald J. tRUMP was, as a teenager, institutionalized.

Of course, the cure didn't take. It couldn't take. For what tRUMP needed was not discipline, it was unconditional love and acceptance by the people who matter most. Again, I am led back to a remark made by a college professor who once said “every infant needs to look into his mother's eyes and see his own reflection. I looked into my mother's eyes and saw confusion.” When Donald looked into his parents eyes, he more than likely saw a mixture of contempt and terror. One doesn't get love from your Sergeant, your drill instructor doesn't tuck you in at night. This is what happens when one is born into a family that has no business having children.  It almost makes one feel sorry for the hapless bastard.

“I often wonder,” wrote conservative political commentator David Brooks, who didn't love Donald Trump. I often wonder who left an affection void that he has tried to fill by winning attention, which is not the same thing. He's turned himself into a marketing strategy. As Michael Cohen said in his testimony on Wednesday, even the presidential campaign was a marketing campaign to build the Trump brand.

“In turning himself into a brand he's turned himself into a human shell, so brittle and gilded that there is no place for people close to him to attach....

“Imagine what your own life would be like if you had no love in it, if you were just using people and being used.” (1)

When love becomes transactional, everything becomes transactional. Everything becomes a commodity, where empathy and compassion have no room, where the terms of the deal are all that matters. A void is left in place of soul or, as David Brooks so adroitly put it, he's turned himself into a human shell. I would add that perhaps he has never been anything but a shell, that any emerging sense of empathy and compassion—so necessary for a well adjusted human being—were aborted in childhood. For this, his parents and extended family have much to account.

“Normal people have moral sentiments,” Observes Brooks. “Normal people are repulsed when the president of their own nation lies, cheats, practices bigotry, allegedly pays off porn star mistresses.

“Were Republican House members enthusiastic or morose as they decided to turn off their own moral circuits, when they decided to be monumentally unconcerned by the fact that their leader may be a moral cretin?

“Do they think that having anesthetized their moral sense in this case they will simply turn it on again down the road?

“This is how moral corrosion happens. Supporting Trump requires daily acts of distancing, a process that means that after a few months you are tolerant of any corruption. You are morally numb to everything” (2)

Precisely. As the latest “twitstorm” flushes the morning sewage into every living room in America, the nation must perform daily acts of ablution, as the country struggles to keep itself clean. Basic hygiene requires it. But cleansing is itself an act of distancing; and it is the only way to, at least momentarily, rid the stench from the nostrils.

Brooks' observation about creeping tolerance and growing numbness is telling and bitter. Look about, in nearly every department of government there brews a scandal in plain sight. The Veterans Administration being run by a trifecta of cronies out of the complex at Mar-a-Lago; the witches brew bubbling at the Environmental Protection Agency where coal, asbestos and mercury are once again in the ascendance; where regulations are being shredded in the name of profit. Ergo: the interior department. And let's not forget the plundering of the public purse in the prison system, our schools, our health care system. We haven't even begun to plumb the depths of scandal swirling about the heads of Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross, or Treasury Secretary Mnuchin. The corruption swirling in this cesspool has become so overwhelming that it dwarfs all previous experience. It is impossible to keep up with it all, the stench paralyses the senses. A major political party has already lost its sensibility, and the rest of the nation may soon follow. What was previously abhorrent becomes normalized and thereby legitimized.

When Cohen told the nation about the man behind the curtain, the Republicans only attacked the veracity of the witness. But, as Gail Collins recently observed:

“Almost everybody who knows Donald Trump appears to be going to prison for lying. Or is awaiting sentencing for lying. Or is facing charges of lying.” (3)

Lies embellishing and supporting this façade; lies that are the hot air that inflate the balloon that is this shell; lies that form the hard surface of this empty shell. A shell filled with nothing but the noxious gas of mendacity; a shell nothing can be allowed to penetrate; a shell to which nothing can attach.

When Cohen told the nation about the man behind the curtain, no one on the committee rose to defend our Caesar Disgustus. You can't defend an empty head, an empty heart, an empty shell.

“An Br'er Putin, he jus' laugh and laugh”

Impeach and Imprison

______________

  1. Brooks, David. “Morality and Michael Cohen” The New York Times. Friday, March 1, 2019. Page A23.
  2. Ibid.
  3. Collins, Gail. “Trump's a Guy Who's Tough To Defend” The New York Times. Thursday, February 28, 2019. Page A27








May 18, 2018

May 15, 2018: Lizard Wisdom, Thugs Gotta Thug, tRUMP Steaks



Two essays appeared last Friday in The New York Times opinion pages, one by David Brooks and the other by Paul Krugman demonstrating not only the promise that is Caesar Disgustus but the pitfalls as well. 


"We're all educated by our peers," wrote David Brooks, "and, over the years, a good portion of Donald Trump's peers have been thugs. Operating in the New York construction world meant dealing with S&A Concrete, co-owned by 'Fat Tony' Salerno of the Genovese crime family, and John Cody, the notorious head of Teamsters Local 282, who was convicted on racketeering and tax evasion charges.
Building casinos in Atlantic City brought Trump into similarly genteel circles. Trump's hero was Roy Cohn, who unfortunately was born too late to serve the emperor, Caligula. To go to Trump parties in the 1980's was to be surrounded by C-list celebrities and shady business types voted Most Likely to be Arraigned in high school." (1)
Trump's latest 'fixer', Michael Cohen is cut from similar cloth.  Brooks notes that he once "worked for a lawyer who pleaded guilty to bribing insurance adjusters.  His ex-business partner in the taxi industry was convicted of assault in New York, arrested on battery in Miami and pleaded guilty to criminal mischief in New Jersey (2). 
"About 15 years ago Cohen set up businesses for two doctors, one of whom was later charged with insurance fraud and grand larceny, the other indicted on racketeering charges.  as a personal injury lawyer, he frequently represented people accused of insurance fraud....
"If not for the Trump and Cohen peer circle", quips Brooks, "white-collar prisons would be sitting empty".  further noting that all this occurred before the two discovered the benefits and delights of conspiring with Russian Oligarchs. (3)

But Brooks, seeking as he does a silver (if not gold--tRUMP is mesmerized by gold) lining behind every dark face, suggests that perhaps there is an 'evil genius' at work here demonstrating an understanding of the world that the so-called 'educated elites' have wholly missed. He cites here our evolving understanding or, perhaps fatally, our misunderstandings with North Korea, China, and Iran.

The educated elite, the Foreign Policy crowd, the readers of "Foreign Affairs" , countless studies by the likes of the "Council on Foreign Affairs", and reports by international agencies, assumed, according to Brooks that that if we treated these nations with deference and respect they would soon be acting like us and become part of one big international family.  

"This is the vanity of the educated class going back for centuries. Since we're obviously so superior, everybody else secretly wants to be like us. It's wrong. Thugs gotta be thug. Religious fanatics gotta fanaticize". (4)
So by engaging in brinkmanship, and picking fights our "bully" tries to demonstrate who, figuratively and, in the case of North Korea quite literally, has the greater nuclear button. As of his writing, these schoolyard tactics have yielded some result; Brooks noting that there has been a warming of the relationship with North Korea, prisoners have been released, a nuclear test facility has been closed. Similarly, in regards to China, the Chinese have promised to lower tariffs on U.S. automobiles. 
 Brooks stopped short, as well he should, from endorsing Caesar Disgustus concluding, rather ambiguously:
"Please don't take this as an endorsement of the Trump foreign policy. I'd feel a lot better if Trump showed some awareness of the complexity of the systems he's disrupting, and the possibly cataclysmic unintended consequences. But there is some lizard wisdom here. The world is a lot more like the Atlantic City real estate market than the G.R.E's." (5)

Perhaps, but with all due respect for our modern Caligula's explicit connections with, and implicit understandings of, the depravity of the human soul, it is dangerous to imply that when the lizard speaks, he speaks words of wisdom. The Jurasic world of dog-eat-dog or, in this case, lizard-eat-lizard, quickly degenerates into the hellish nightmare of a Hobbesian "State of Nature", which, in a nuclear age, will leave few, if any survivors.  

Indeed, in the days immediately following Brooks' cautious optimism, North Korea has cancelled meetings with South Korea and has threatened to cancel the upcoming summit with tRUMP.   

The difficulty in tipping one's hat, however furtively, to our modern Caligula was hinted at by economist Paul Krugman in an accompanying essay on the same opinion page. "Let Them Eat Trump Steaks" (6), Krugman exclaimed, in reference to yet another of the business 'geniuses' failed enterprises. 

"In general, Donald Trump is notoriously uninterested in policy details", noted Klugman in staggering understatement. "It has long been obvious, for example, that he never bothered to find out what his one major legislative victory, the 2017 tax cut, actually did. Similarly, it's pretty clear that he had no idea what was actually in the Iran agreement he just repudiated.
"In each case, it was about ego rather than substance: scoring a 'win,' undoing his predecessor's achievement.". (7)

That, and as Krugman points out, his overweening mendacity, his hatred of the idea that someone, somewhere is on public assistance. The obscenity of this Krugman excoriates, pointing out that Disgustus and his Ilk have been sucking the public teat for their entire lives. But this is fodder for another essay. What I want to do is go back to the original observation: Disgustus has no mind for policy, particularly public policy. He is willfully ignorant and wears his ignorance like a crown.  

It is this ignorance, ignorance squared so that he is ignorant of that which he is ignorant, that makes this man so dangerous. Tony Schwartz, the real author of "The Making of the Deal", explained in numerous interviews and at a speech given at Oxford University leading up to the U.S. election, that he simply couldn't get tRUMP to sit down and explain his deals. Instead, Schwartz called the other parties to get explanations of what had transpired. To his dumbfounded amazemen,t he discovered that their understandings and that of tRUMP almost never coincided. Each party, after a 'deal' was struck, walked away with an entirely different understanding of what had transpired and what had been agreed to.  

Now we have Disgustus--desperate to accomplish anything--praising the North Korean leader for some small concessions made during the build-up to an "historic" (with Disgustus everything is in superlatives), summit. But the North Koreans have reason to be cautious, for as the talks loom near on the horizon, the U.S. and South Korea engage in joint military exercises right on the North Korean border--a subject long sensitive to the North Koreans, and about which they have long voiced their outrage. Moreover, on the brink of the meetings, Disgustus unilaterally withdraws from the agreement with Iran over Iran's nuclear program isolating this country not only from our European allies but breaking an agreement reached in conjunction with Russia and China as well. Why then should anyone trust the U.S.? Qadaffi trusted us and where did he end up?

The danger here is serious and multiple. If such a summit does occur, it must not take place with only the two principles meeting together. Several nations and observers must be present for
Disgustus can be relied upon to do no prep work, study no history or issues, and appear before our adversaries as but-ignorant as sloth will allow. And we can rest assured that he will compound this ignorance by declaring to the world in as many superlatives as his limited vocabulary can conjure the outlines of an agreement that was never put upon the table laying the foundation for later claims of Korean bad faith and the need for drastic actions. This is what happens when a narcissistic sociopath who operates in his own closed universe dances upon the world stage.  


"An Br'er Putin, he jus' laugh and laugh"

Impeach and Imprison

_______________

(1). Brooks, David. "Trump's Lizard Wisdom" The New York Times. Friday, May 11, 2018. Pg. A27

(2). Ibid
(3). Ibid
(4). Ibid
(5). Ibid
(6). Krugman, Paul. "Let Them Eat Trump Steaks" The New York Times, Friday, May 11, 2018. Pg. A27
(7). Ibid


Apr 22, 2016

April 22, 2016: Babbling Brooks, Experience Slow to Instruct, Giving Voice to Doubt


 
Political commentator and columnist David Brooks wrote in a recent “New York Times” (1) essay lamenting the emergence of Donald Trump that Trumpism, such as it is, represents a paradigm shift in conservative thinking and, by extension, an opportunity to redefine conservatism.  The problem, as always with conservatism is that, as the Brooks’ effort clearly demonstrates, conservatives first fail to recognize the shortcomings of their own intellectual constructions and secondly they fail further to recognize the brazen internal contradictions between their major and minor premises and the conclusions they divine therefrom.  The result, all too predictably are babbling Brooks of nonsense.

Brooks rightly now describes the current Republican malaise as “groaning under the Reagan Orthodoxy” (2) that somehow went from a Rising Tide America to a Coming Apart America.

Now along comes Trump whom Brooks describes as an “Angel of Destruction”, blowing to “smithereens” the comfortable old bromides.  “He represents not only a rejection of the existing Reaganite establishment, but also a rejection of Reaganite foreign policy (he is less globalist) and Reaganite domestic policy (he is friendlier to the state).”  Trump, in Brooks’ view is “prompting what Thomas Kuhn, in his theory of scientific revolutions, called a model crisis”.  Declaring Trump totally devoid of any ideas or policies, Brooks concludes that Trump “will almost certainly go down to a devastating defeat either in the general election or—God help us—as the worst president in American history.” (3) 

But, alas for Brooks at least, every looming political catastrophe bears a silver lining.  Now is the chance, he writes, for a “mental purging: casting aside many existing mental categories and presuppositions, to shift your identity from one with a fixed mindset to one in which you are a seeker and open to anything.  The second step is probably embedding: going out and seeing America with fresh eyes and listening to American voices with fresh ears….” (4)

Brooks then waxes on about the need to replace the soulless and loveless Trumpist vision with compassion, moving conservative doctrine to a more sociologically compassionate philosophy and away from the fetish conservatives demonstrate for tax cuts, enterprise zones, and the “utility-driven individual”. “Somehow”, Brooks writes, “the Republican Party will have to rediscover a language of loving thy neighbor…. because today’s problems relate to binding a fragmenting society, reweaving family and social connections, relating across the diversity of a globalized world.  Homo economicus is a myth and conservatism needs a worldview that is accurate about Human nature.” (5)   Indeed, so it does.

Again, to paraphrase Gibbon, if with regard to our conservative brethren “experience is powerless to instruct”, we must at least give Brooks credit here for some well-intentioned, if not long overdue soul-searching.  It is not often that we find this kind of courage exhibited so publicly among the chattering class.

But, alas, our friend has miles to go before he sleeps.  We can begin with the failure to honestly apprehend our national experience.  Referring to the legacy of his patron Saint Ronald Reagan, Brooks openly declares that “We’ve gone from Rising Tide America to Coming Apart America”, from the “Reagan worldview…based on the idea that a rising tide would lift all boats. But that’s clearly no longer true.” (6)  It never was.

Brooks, like all of the chattering class, the myriad talking heads that sometimes enlighten but often pollute the airwaves, is a victim of his own self-imposed myopia.  He has spent a lifetime caught in the confines of the Washington Beltway and the conservative echo-chamber.  The fact is that had he made even a modest effort to expand his horizons and, therefore, his peripheral vision, he would have discovered that the Kennedy, not Reagan, dictum that a ‘rising tide lifts all boats’ while administered by a good Liberal-Democratic administration became, in malignant conservative hands, more properly “a rising tide lifts all yachts”. 

To discover this, Brother Brooks would not have been required to read the collective works of Karl Marx, or even those of Jeremy Bentham.  He would not have been required to consult with pols like Ted Kennedy, or even a Bernie Sanders.  He would not have had to search in vain for a conservative stink-tank offering an alternative point of view.  All he would have had to do was consult the likes of Kevin Phillips—author of Nixon’s Southern Strategy—and longtime card-carrying Republican who has written extensively about the lingering effects of Reaganomics.  Beginning in the late 80’s right after Reagan left office, Phillips began to publish the early returns and by 1993 he declared straightforwardly in his book “Boiling Point” (7), that the middle class had lost ground, if not taken a thrashing, under Reagan—even during the High Tide period of the 80’s when the policies first went into effect.  It hasn’t got any better in the ensuing quarter century as administrations both Democratic and Republican have ratified the inspired stupidity of what the host of “Death Valley Days” had wrought.  The returns have been in now for over quarter century, we are now nearly two generations into this failed experiment and only now a lonely soul far off on the political wrong begins to give voice to doubt.  It has been a long time coming.

What I am suggesting here is that Brooks has not gone nearly far enough in casting aside long held categories and presuppositions, beginning of course with the category that man is entirely a utility-driven economic animal and with the supposition that unfettered capital will ‘raise all boats’.  The first is a deeply one-dimensional, if not completely self-serving (from the view of the capitalist elites) proposition and the second has never been demonstrated in the whole of human experience.  Indeed, precisely the opposite occurs with nauseating certainty. 

Secondly the conclusions divined by late 20th century conservatism are wholly at odds, it should now be painfully apparent with the objective, empirical, measurable reality—as writers like Phillips have so laboriously and conclusively demonstrated.  Plainly one simply cannot institute a regime in which a form of Social Darwinism is fostered which does not in the end strain the social, economic and political bonds to the breaking point.  A clear contradiction emerges in which the “freedom” of those who through effort and intelligence, or inheritance and sloth, assume such massive advantages as to stifle the aspirations if not the very well-being of the rest of society.  Society bifurcates into the Have’s and Have-Not’s.  The Middle Class gives ground, as does the ‘political center’.   Politics becomes a reflection of the divisions now deep in a society coming apart. 

It's the Coming Apart America, in Brooks phrase, that Trumpism represents.  In subsequent columns Brooks admonishes us to forge ‘intermediate’ relationships, and make ‘Covenants’ with each other (8).  All that is well and good but he is overlooking the necessary first step and that is to recognize the damage that Reagan had wrought and to repudiate it. “Reagan orthodoxy”, wrote Brooks, “…. was right for the 1980’s but has become increasingly obsolete” (9).  This represents not even the first step toward honesty.  No, David.  Reagan Orthodoxy is a purely 19th century construct and was obsolete at conception; that it ill-suited the 1980’s has been demonstrated by your fellow conservative and former Republican Kevin Phillips.   No, David, there are reasons why the country and your movement is groaning under the weight of the Reagan Orthodoxy and that is that it never worked. 

And now, your movement and your party are finally being abandoned as those who create the wealth through their labor have become painfully aware that they do not share the same interests or the same world-view as those who appropriate the value of that labor and manage it for their own selfish ends.

Trump would be the worst president in American history?  That is quite an assertion betraying a pique unbecoming a man revisiting the country with fresh eyes and ears.  In any case it may be an abyss too far.  It is, for instance, difficult to imagine a President Trump sending troops off to the frontier as states secede from the union, or playing guitar while a major city drowns.

_____

(1). Brooks, David. “The Post-Trump Era” “New York Times” March 25, 2016.  Page A23

(2). ibid

(3). ibid

(4). ibid

(5). ibid

(6). ibid

(7). see Phillips, Kevin. “Boiling Point: Democrats, Republicans, and the Decline of Middle-Class Prosperity”. 1993 Random House, New York. 307 pages

(8). Brooks, David. “How Covenants Make Us” “New York Times”  April 5, 2016. Page A23

      Brooks, David.  “How to Fix Politics” New York Times” April 12, 2016. Page A23

(9). Op Cit