Showing posts with label Distribution of Wealth. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Distribution of Wealth. Show all posts

Dec 10, 2015

December 9, 2015: Old Fashioned Oligarchy, Athens and Democracy, Cancer on the Republic



“We are now in a free fall toward old fashioned oligarchy—that noxious, thieving, tyrannical, oppressive species of government that America’s original settlers fled Europe to escape.”

          ----Robert F. Kennedy Jr. “Billionaires and Ballot Bandits”

 Kennedy isn’t alone in his assessment.  A widely reported study conducted at Princeton and Northwestern universities (1) released last April, and dubbed by some the “DUH Report”, concluded:

 "The central point that emerges from our research is that economic elites and organized groups representing business interests have substantial independent impacts on US government policy, while mass-based interest groups and average citizens have little or no independent influence.” (2)

Oligarchy, defined here as “a form of government in which power is vested in a dominant class and a small group exercises control over the general population,” (3) has now become documented fact.  Reviewing over 18,000 policies enacted between 1981 and 2002, the study found that the “resulting data empirically verifies that U.S. policies are determined by the economic elite.” (4)

This, of course, comes as no surprise either to those of us who have stood witness to the usurpations of economic and political power; nor to those millions who have suffered diminution of circumstance and future prospects through the foreclosure of the American Dream.

It also goes a long way to explain the utter unresponsiveness of this government as it does the bidding of the corporate and economic elites but consistently fails to address the underlying causes of our current economic malaise; as well as the complete ‘tone deafness’ of the corporate heads and political elites to the pain inflicted by inspiringly myopic and self-serving economic policies.  From a CEO of a fast-food chain blaming his workers for their poverty—accusing them of bad judgement, it seems, for accepting employment at his wretched business in the first place—to one JEB Bush, in a singular act of contempt and callousness, admonishing the poor not to organize for higher wages but to instead work longer hours. (5)

But the threat goes much further than the devastation of the American middle class.  As noted in previous posts, a thriving middle class is a perquisite to a healthy republican order.  Without a strong and a commanding middle class, the rich will plunder society and first attempt to buy power they will, failing that, call out the military and usurp it.

 The above quote by Robert Kennedy was posted on Facebook in a meme by a friend of mine.  I commented on the post as follows:

 “And it is also the reason that the Athenians originally created Democracy. The oligarchy that misruled Athens produced a revolution that produced the world's first Democratic government. Declaring the oligarchy, a 'tyranny' the Athenians not only introduced a new term in the political lexicon but went about the business of reigning in on the abuses of the economic elite through direct political participation. Yes, at its origin, Democracy was about controlling wealth.”

Yes, Democracy, at its origin, was about controlling wealth, and about the equitable distribution of it.  To be a true democrat one must be about economic justice.  This is why those who support the interests of the emergent oligarchy are about the business of limiting the franchise, gerrymandering the political landscape, erecting obstacles and limiting access to voting, and changing the way we finance elections so that they can be outright and legally purchased. 

At base the modern conservative movement, and the oligarchs they serve, is fundamentally anti- democratic and anti-republican.  The conservative movement betrays the promise of the democratic experiment and is a cancer upon the republic.

_______

(1).  The report was picked up by both the BBC and UPI wire service. See http://www.upi.com/Top_News/US/2014/04/16/The-US-is-not-a-democracy-but-an-oligarchy-study-concludes/2761397680051/ as well as: http://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-echochambers-27074746

(2). See the UPI report.

(3). Ibid

(4). Ibid

(5). http://news.yahoo.com/jeb-bush-people-longer-hours-235206730.html#

Sep 15, 2015

September 14, 2015: To Sustain a Republic, Wealth Must Be Distributed, Majority Must Have the Wealth.


 
"Wealth, like suffrage, must be considerably distributed, to sustain a democratic republic; and hence, whatever draws a considerable proportion of either into a few hands, will destroy it. As power follows wealth, the majority must have wealth or lose power." (1)
                          ----John Taylor, "An Inquiry into the Principles and Policy of the Government of the United States" (1814)
 
John Taylor 1753-1724, otherwise known as John Taylor of Caroline, was a contemporary of Thomas Jefferson, John Adams, and James Madison.  Present at the creation of the republic, he served as United States Senator from Virginia on three separate occasions, 1792-1794, 1803, and from 1822 until his death in 1824.

“English legal historian M.J.C. Vile views Taylor as "in some ways the most impressive political theorist that America has produced." [2] Historian Clyde N. Wilson describes Taylor as "the systematic philosopher of Jeffersonian democracy,"[3] and as "representing 'both a conservative allegiance to local community and inherited ways and a radical-populist suspicion of capitalism, ‘progress,’ government and routine logrolling politics.'"[4] According to historian Adam L. Tate, Taylor was "an agrarian who 'viewed happiness as possession of family, farm, and leisure,' had no great love for organized religion, social hierarchy, and other such traditional institutions."[5] "Taylor took solid liberal ground in holding that men were a mixture of good and evil. Self-interest was the only real constant in human action. . . . . Indeed, while other thinkers, from Thomas Jefferson to Federalist John Adams, agonized over the need for a virtuous citizenry, Taylor took the view that 'the principles of a society may be virtuous, though the individuals composing it are vicious.'" [6] Taylor's solution to the effects of factionalism was to "remove the base from under the stock jobbers, the banks, the paper money party, the tariff-supported manufacturers, and so on; destroy the system of patronage by which the executive has corrupted the legislature; bring down the usurped authority of the Supreme Court." [7] "The more a nation depends for its liberty on the qualities of individuals, the less likely it is to retain it. By expecting publick good from private virtue, we expose ourselves to publick evils from private vices." [8] (9)

Described as at the ‘intersection of republicanism and classical liberalism’ Taylor stands as a precursor in a line of political thought that defending the sovereignty of the several states would lead inexorably to the philosophies of John C. Calhoun and the politics of  interposition, nullification and secession.  His defense of slavery would likewise anticipate the works of Edmund Ruffin and George Fitzhugh, laying the intellectual justification for the antebellum south’s ‘peculiar institution’.

Why, then, would Professor Reich light upon what are now the obscure writings of an early 19th century politician and political philosopher, and an early apologist for the ‘lost cause’, in order to make a point about contemporary American politics? 

I can’t speak for the professor but I would suggest it is precisely because Taylor (a relative of a future United States President Zachery Taylor) represents not only significant views held by many of our founding fathers, but because he represents a significant part of the American Political Tradition influencing our politics today.  I am referring here to the strain of classical liberalism that today would be called libertarian, emphasizing local control, state’s rights, and limited government.  But note here how, in an early formulation of what would become libertarian conservatism, one finds clearly evident ‘populist’ economic formulations that would lead Taylor to oppose like Jefferson, the economic policies of the Federalist Alexander Hamilton. The distrust of banking in general and central banks in particular has a long history in this country as Taylor’s writings suggest.  He was not alone.  From Jefferson to Jackson to the “Greenback” party and William Jennings Bryan’s excoriation of the ‘cross of gold’ (referring to the Gold Standard); to FDR’s struggles with Wall Street and the Banking industry; to many on the political ‘right’ today who advocate the abolition of the Federal Reserve banking system; Americans from the first have consistently exhibited a great unease with the centralization of economic power.  

Today we can easily dismiss Taylor’s views on race and slavery, as we can dismiss his view that state sovereignty trumps all.  The Civil War changed all that.  But like Richard Henry Lee, James Madison, Thomas Jefferson and others Taylor reminds us that many, if not most, of those who wrote and ratified the founding documents of this nation were deeply distrustful of concentrations of economic power.  They held these views not because they were against ‘free markets’ but because they knew that there is a relationship between economic and political power; that one inexorably produces the other, and that rule by oligopoly would mean an end to the democratic experiment.   Indeed it was precisely to wrest control from the oligarchs that the citizens of Athens rebelled and established a Democracy, demonstrating as they did not only the reasons and justification for the citizens to seize control but that Democracy and a redistribution of wealth have, from the beginning gone hand-in-hand.  To defend Democracy or, in our case, a republican form of government, one must inevitably confront the questions concerning the distribution of wealth in society.  It is comforting here to re-confirm, the thesis of  Arthur Schlesinger, Jr. in his “The Age of Jackson”, that the founding fathers were not only suspicious of combinations and cartels but advocated and worked to regulate, or outright prevent, their formation.

I have previously written about this, expressing precisely these points. (10)  That what differentiates a true republican government from a so-called “Banana Republic” is the existence of a healthy, powerful and indeed controlling middle class; and that, therefore, it necessarily follows that to wage war upon the middle class is to wage war upon the republic itself.  Taylor understood this, as did Jefferson, Lee, Madison and Adams.  Modern conservatives do not.

_______

 1. Robert Reich, Facebook post 8/28/15

2.Joseph R. Stromberg, Country Ideology, Republicanism, and Libertarianism: The Thought of John Taylor of Caroline, The Journal of Libertarian Studies, Vol VI, No. 1, 35 (Winter 1982) (citing M.J.C. Vile, Constitutionalism and the Separation of Powers, 167 (Oxford: Clarendon Press 1967)).

3. Wilson, Clyde (2011-11-03) A Little Rebellion, Chronicles

4. Hales, Dylan (2008-12-01) Left Turn Ahead, The American Conservative

5. McCarthy, Daniel (2005-08-01) Liberty and Order in the Slave Society, The American Conservative

6. Stromberg, pp. 39-40.

7. Id. at 41 (quoting Grant McConnell, "John Taylor and the Democratic Tradition," Western Political Quarterly, Vol. 4, No. 1, 27 (March 1951)).

8. Forrest McDonald, Novus Ordo Seclorum 75 (Lawrence: University of Kansas Press 1985) (quoting Taylor).

9. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Taylor_of_Caroline.

10. http://wandererandshadow.blogspot.com/2008/01/january-13-2008-banana-republic.html