May 31, 2020

May 31, 2020: Making a Cult, Grandiosity of Glory, Intellectual Straight-Jackets


"A doctrine, any doctrine, is an intellectual straight-jacket"
       ----from The Quotations of Chairman Joe

A successful mass movement, Eric Hoffer reminds us, requires concerted action and self-sacrifice. All the other characteristics, organization, propaganda etc., are only means to elicit self-sacrifice and the marshal that sacrifice toward the desired ends. Self-sacrifice is, then, at the core of any mass movement.

“To ripen a person for self-sacrifice he must be stripped of his individual identity and distinctness. He must cease to be George, Hans, Ivan or Tadao—a human atom with an existence bounded by birth and death. The most drastic way to achieve this end is by the complete assimilation of the individual into a collective body. The fully assimilated individual does not see himself and others as human beings. When asked who he is, his automatic response is that he is a German, a Russian, a Japanese, a Christian, a Moslem, a member of a certain tribe or family. He has no purpose, worth and destiny apart from his collective body; and as long as that body lives he cannot really die...

“The effacement of individual separateness must be thorough. In every act, however trivial, the individual must by some ritual associate himself with the congregation, the tribe, the party, etcetera. His joys and sorrows, his pride and confidence must spring from the fortunes and capacities of the group rather than from his individual prospects and abilities. Above all, he must never feel alone. Though stranded on a desert island, he must still feel that he is under the eyes of the group. To be case out from the group should be equivalent to being cut off from life.” (1)

The movement, the cause, is everything. It is for these reasons that ritual was introduced. It is for these reasons that some denominations require daily observances, that some denominations require church attendance several times a week. Why religions often wear certain clothing, adopt certain culinary practices, or effect certain behaviors. It brands the devout with an identity, often one that cannot easily be momentarily put aside, much the same as the military crew cut brands the soldier so that when he is home on leave he, even if he discards the uniform, takes his new identity with him.

The military is a good example. It takes a lot to get a man to sacrifice everything, his home, his primary relationships, perhaps his very life. It takes a lot more to get a man to kill another man. Those who have studied battle universally report that many of the shots fired are intended to miss. Often a man will go through the motions though his rifle be empty. Killing is much easier at a distance. Tellingly, most of those who died during the First World War were killed not by machine gun fire but by artillery shells fired from long range. To get a man to kill requires the total submission of the self to the group. Any soldier will tell you that in the end, it wasn't the cause that mattered in the fight, it was the group who fought alongside. The cause could have been, and universally is, anything. The goals of every war change repeatedly: the Civil War from preserving the union to the abolition of slavery, the First World War from the resistance to aggression to making the world safe for Democracy; the War of Jenkins' Ear became in short order the War of Spanish Succession. What doesn't change is loyalty to the group. This is the cement that holds any movement together.

But what actuates this loyalty? Certainly not the cause, for the cause can be anything. What activates loyalty is separateness,in a word, Identity. An identity that must be maintained by constantly contrasting the group with the other. Only by maintaining the boundaries with between us and them can the group identity have any hope of longevity. And how does one maintain those boundaries? Through fear, loathing and, foremost, hatred. As Hitler once explained: if the Jews hadn't existed it would have been necessary to invent them. The use of scapegoats and the hatreds they engender, are always the handmaidens of propaganda. Hatred is the palliative of choice.

Perhaps a better example is that of the Christian Church whose Revelations, those lurid apocalyptic terrors binding the faithful has, over millennia identified the anti-Christ as, variously, ancient Rome, the Russians, and the Germans even, with Luther, the mother church, the Vatican itself. More recently the faithful, especially the evangelicals, have looked closer to home: Barack Obama, the Deep State, and that most fearful of all, grandmother Hillary Clinton. The object binding them together, that is the object of fear and loathing; of hatred and hostility, changes with the seasons, what doesn't change is their identity and the hatreds that manifest it. For the True Believer does not see himself or others as human beings; he does not see at all.

Then there is, as Hoffer points, out, the question of Glory:

“Glory is largely a theatrical concept. There is no string for glory without a vivid awareness of an audience---the knowledge that our mighty deeds will come to the ears of our contemporaries or 'of those who are to be. We are ready to sacrifice our true, transitory self for the imaginary eternal self we are building up, by our heroic deeds, in the opinion and imagination of others.

In the practice of mass movements, make-believe plays perhaps a more enduring role than any other factor. When faith and the power to persuade or coerce are gone, make-believe lingers on. There is no doubt that in staging its processions, parades, rituals and ceremonials, a mass movement touches a responsive chord in every heart. Even the most sober-minded are carried away by the sight of an impressive mass spectacle.”(2)

By jingo, who doesn't love a parade? Especially a military parade, so the tanks now roll through the streets of Washington

All mass movements deprecate the present as a mere prelude to a Glorious Future. It's never a more modest safe and secure future, but always invokes the grandiosity of Glory. The maggot hats “Make America Great Again” is always cast in superlatives, never so modest as “make America good again”, much less “Make America Decent”. And, if the past is put into service at all it is always a truncated, idealized version meant to further the cause to more dubious ends.

Finally, there is the question of Doctrine. All doctrines are intellectual straight-jackets.

“The effectiveness of doctrine does not come from it meaning but from its certitude. Now doctrine however profound and sublime will be effective unless it is presented as the embodiment of the one and only truth. It must be the one word from which all things are and all things speak. Crude absurdities, trivial nonsense and sublime truths are equally potent in readying people for self-sacrifice if they are accepted as the sole, eternal truth.

“It is obvious, therefore, that in order to be effective a doctrine must not be understood, but has to be believed in. We can be absolutely certain only about things we do not understand. A doctrine that is understood is shorn of its strength. Once we understand a thing, it is as if it has originated in us. And, clearly, those who are asked to renounce the self and sacrifice it cannot see eternal certitude in anything that originates in that self...

If a doctrine is not unintelligible, it has to be vague; and if neither unintelligible nor vague, it has to be unverifiable. One has to get to heaven or the distant future to determine the truth of an effective doctrine. When some part of the doctrine is relatively simple, there is a tendency among the faithful to complicate and obscure it. Simple words are made pregnant with meaning and made to look like symbols in a secret message. There is thus an illiterate air about the most literate true believer. He seems to use words as if he were ignorant of their true meaning. Hence, too, his taste for quibbling, hair-splitting and scholastic tortuousness. (3)

Yeah, even unto the speaking in tongues.

To be in possession of absolute truth is to assassinate all curiosity, remove from one's vision all of the wonder of the universe. “It is startling," observed Hoffer, “to realize how much unbelief is necessary to make belief possible”. Indeed it is, for one must, like a child, suspend disbelief in order to make belief possible. Or, in the words of our Caesar Disgustus, “don't believe what you read and hear” for your lying eyes deceive you. Faith tRUMPs everything. You don't ask questions when god's on your side. 


Mass movements, relying as they do upon alienation and resentments are, Hoffer instructs us, not only occasionally necessary but very malleable. Not all alienation is harmful, nor are all discontents. It is through alienation, that is the stepping back, that real intellectual inquiry begins, it is through alienation and it's discontents that the search to improve things originates. So mass movements are necessary in order to cleanse society of corruption, improve efficiencies, and create, in the immortal words of our founders, “a more perfect union”. It is in the malleability of the beast that the problem lies, for as stated throughout these posts the popular passions, like anything else, can be marshaled for good or ill. The question is who is to lead it and to what ends. Therein lies the tragedy of our times. For it fell upon a common and corrupt carnival barker from Queens who knows only how to vandalize.

____________

  1. See Hoffer, Eric. The True Believer. Op. Cit. Pages 60-61
  2. Ibid. Pages 65-66
  3. Ibid. Pages 76-77













May 27, 2020

May 26, 2020: The Making a Cult, The Misfits, To Be Somebody



As Hoffer observes, The inert mass of a nation, for instance, is in its middle section. The decent, average people who do the nation's work in cities and on the land are worked upon and shaped by minorities at both ends—the best and the worst.

“The superior individual, whether in politics, literature, science, commerce or industry, plays a large role in shaping a nation, but so do individuals at the other extreme—the failures, misfits, outcasts, criminals, and all those who have lost their footing, or never had one, in the ranks of respectable humanity” (1) the latter being an exhaustive description of our would-be Caesar.

“The reason that the inferior elements of a nation can exert a marked influence on its course is that they are wholly without reverence toward the present. They see their lives and the present as spoiled beyond remedy and they are ready to waste and wreck both; hence their recklessness and their will to chaos and anarchy. They also crave to dissolve their spoiled, meaningless selves in some soul-stirring spectacular communal undertaking—hence the proclivity for united action.” (2)

This describes tRUMP and all that he represents to the proverbial Tee. The war on the Obama administration and all that went before—the war upon the world he inherited. The need to waste and wreck, the vandalism of institutions. And the chaos that follows.

The early recruits are among the most disaffected. Hoffer lists several: the poor, misfits, outcasts, minorities, adolescent youth, the ambitious, those in grip of vice or obsession, the impotent, the inordinately selfish, the bored, the sinners. (3) There are reasons that tRUMP makes war on education claiming to love the uneducated and counts the nations motorcycle gangs among his greatest supporters.

The Poor:

“Not all who are poor are frustrated. Some of the poor stagnating in the slums of the cities are smug in their decay. They shudder at the thought of life outside their familiar cesspool. Even the respectable poor, when their poverty is of long standing, remain inert. They are awed by the immutability of the order of thing. It takes a cataclysm—an invasion, a plague or some other communal disaster—to open their eyes to the transitoriness of the 'eternal order.'

“It is usually those whose poverty is relatively recent, the 'new poor,' who throb with the ferment of frustration. The memory of better things is as fire to their veins. They are the disinherited and dispossessed who respond to every rising mass movement. It was the new poor in seventeenth century England who ensured the success of the Puritan Revolution. During the movement of enclosure, thousands of landlords drove of their tenants and turned their fields into pastures. 'Strong and active peasant, enamored of the soil that nurtured them, were transformed into wageworkers or sturdy beggars;...city streets were filled with paupers;. It was this mass of the dispossessed who furnished the recruits for Cromwell's army.

“In Germany and Italy the new poor coming from a ruined middle class formed the chief support of the Nazi and Fascist revolutions.”(4)

Abject poverty makes not a revolutionary. It isn't simply that a pall of permanence descends upon the victim's head, it isn't simply that all self worth and self confidence are beaten, by intent and by circumstance, out of the soul of the downtrodden. It's also because of, in modern parlance, the dysfunctional behaviors into which one is bred, born and raised. All this, after a measure, assumes the cloak of normal. Divorce, domestic violence, terror with and intimidation by the unfamiliar, all lead to a lack of striving—interpreted by the larger society as laziness and sloth. They are comfortable in their cesspools, as Hoffer puts it, not out of devotion or attachment but out of fear and intimidation. This is why poverty is so intractable and why the poor are hard to politically motivate.

“The poor on the borderline of starvation live purposeful lives. To be engaged in a desperate struggle for food and shelter is to be wholly free from a sense of futility. The goals are concrete and immediate. Every meal is a fulfillment; to go to sleep on a full stomach is a triumph; and every windfall a miracle. What need could they have for 'an inspiring super individual goal which would give meaning and dignity to their lives?' they are immune to the appeal of a mass movement.”(4)

No, it is those who suffering downward mobility, those who have fallen are fear they are about to fall who are the fodder of mass movements.

The Misfits

Here Hoffer lists the temporary misfits; young adults seeking niche in life, people going through serious life changes, divorce, career change, unemployment, which he describes as...”restless, dissatisfied and haunted by the fear that their best years will be wasted before they reach their goal. They are receptive to the preaching of a proselytizing movement and yet do nt always make staunch converts. For they are not irrevocably estranged from the self; they do not see it as irremediably spoiled. It is easy for them to conceive an autonomous existence that is purposeful and hopeful. The slightest evidence of progress and success reconciles them with the world and their selves...

“The permanent misfits are those who because of a lack of talent or some irreparable defect in body or mind cannot do the one thing for which their whole being craves. No achievement, however spectacular, in other fields can give them a sense of fulfillment. Whatever they undertake becomes a passionate pursuit; but they never arrive, never pause. They demonstrate the fact that we can never have enough of that which we really do not want, and that we run the fastest and farthest when we run from ourselves.” (6)

These words could have been lifted verbatim and applied by Donald tRUMP's niece Mary who has recently published a book about her uncle entitled, appropriately enough, “Too Much and Never Enough: How My Family Created the World's Most Dangerous Man”. It was Mary who leaked the trove of financial documents to The New York Times that revealed to the world that in the 1980's tRUMP the businessman lost more than a billion dollars.

Totally lacking in talent, with every defect of body and mind, Mary tells about how his sister did Donald's homework and that he hired a bright friend to take his college entrance exams. It remains unclear who took the tests and who did the homework while in college, but it is clear that he he learned nothing. Growing up in his father's shadow, Donald sees himself as irredeemably spoiled—that is, worthless. How else does one respond to being exiled from home and shunted off to a military school? That no matter what he achieves will never be, in his mind's eye—seen in his father's reflection--enough. So he adheres himself to a movement, rising by the basest means to lead it. Speaking always in superlatives, his outlandish pomposity and grandiosity belies a shattered sense of self-worth. He is always in motion, always deflecting He is always running, but never arrives. He's running to stand still.

This is the picture of our disgusting Caesar his niece, a clinical psychologist, confirms to the nation. The inordinately selfish seeing perhaps unlimited opportunities in the presidency and bored with the litany of failures that daily visited tRUMP tower, from forays into the airline industry, to casinos, wine production, steaks and even a 'university', Disgustus, always drawn to shiny object settled upon nothing less that the presidency itself. Commandeering an emerging mass movement was, given his age, Donald J. tRUMP's last chance to become somebody. And the adoring multitude sees in him their own yearnings and their own reflection. Man makes god in his own image, likewise the multitude. Our Caesar Disgustus is nothing more and nothing less than a mass conceit.

An Br'er Putin, he jus' laugh and laugh

Flush this turd, November 3rd.

______

  1. Ibid. Page 29
  2. Ibid. Page 30
  3. Ibid. Page 30
  4. Ibid. Page 31
  5. Ibid. Page 32
  6. Ibid. Page 50

May 7, 2020

May 7, 2020: Making a Cult, Denial of Self, Identity Politics.



The next few posts will be, in light of the cancer of tRUMPism now racing through the body politic, an effort to divine the nature of cultism. For this purpose, I will revisit the writings of Eric Hoffer, the itinerant philosopher who published his seminal work The True Believer, nearly 70 years ago.

The True Believer, Thoughts on the Nature of Mass Movements, was written in the aftermath of the Second World War in an effort to divine the nature of political movements and, more precisely, what it is about the converted that leads them to follow blindly as well as why the so willingly do so. The True Believer is an important work which, along with Jose Ortega de Gassett's Revolt of the Masses, should be required reading in every public school. These works are certainly more profound and penetrating than Orwell's Animal Farm, and head-and-shoulders above anything written by Ayn Rand or Henry David Thoreau. But, alas, Hoffer doesn't take prisoners, he doesn't pander to the masses, instead he reveals what they really are and why they are so easily misled; features that do not recommend the work to boards of education.

Query: What makes a mass movement? Answer: The True Believer. What makes a True Believer? That is the subject now under discussion.

Prospect of Change: Many who join an emerging revolutionary movement are drawn by prospect of change.

“Not so obvious is the fact that religious and nationalist movements too can be vehicles for change. Some kind of widespread enthusiasm is apparently needed for the realization of vast and rapid change.”(2) The overweening desire for change can originate in a deep emotional need to climb the social or economic ladder, or it can—as several historians of American History have pointed out—be motivated by displaced elites; men of property and standing who have been shouldered aside by new wealth and new captains of industry and power. The progressive movement of the late 19th and early 20th centuries in the United States is an example of the latter phenomenon.

Embracing a radical prospect of change implies deep unhappiness with the present state of affairs, and represents an inclination to make war upon the present. But this war is conducted by a select few of the population. The very wealthy and well-to-do, of course, are content with the status quo. But it is not the downtrodden who are the fodder of the revolutionist, for they know that the situation—any situation—is hopeless and, if change comes, it is likely not to be beneficial. No, real mass movements are middle class affairs. It was the lawyers and burgers (small businessmen) and professionals who led the French Revolution. The Nazis, at the beginning, were financed by middle class housewives. It is those who have lost their status, and those that fear its loss, who compose the building materials of mass movements.

Renunciation of Self and Identity Politics:

“There is a fundamental difference between the appeal of a mass movement and the appeal of a practical organization. The practical organization offers opportunities for self-advancement, and its appeal is mainly to self-interest. On the other hand, a mass movement, particularly in its active revivalist phase, appeals not to those intent on bolstering and advancing a cherished self, but to those who crave to be rid of an unwanted self. A mass movement attracts and holds a following not because it can satisfy a desire for self-advancement, but because it can satisfy the passion for self-renunciation.

“People who see their lives as irremediably spoiled cannot find a worthwhile purpose in self-advancement. The prospect of an individual career cannot stir them to a single mighty effort, nor can it evoke in them faith and a single-minded dedication. They look upon self-interest as on something tainted and evil; something unclean and unlucky. Anything undertaken under the auspices of the self seems to them foredoomed. Nothing that has its roots and reasons in the self can be good and noble. Their innermost craving is for a new life—a rebirth—or,failing this, a chance to acquire new elements of pride, confidence, hope, a sense of purpose and worth by an identification with the holy cause. An active mass movement offers them opportunities for both. If they join the movement as full converts they are reborn to a new life in its close-knit collective body, or if attracted as sympathizers they find elements of pride, confidence and purpose identifying themselves with the efforts, achievements and prospects of the movement.”(3)

Those who crave to be rid of an unwanted self or, perhaps, those who have been made to feel that one must reject that self. Luther, for instance, taught that we are, in the eyes of god, nothing but dirty rags. This is a lesson impressed upon even—and especially—the youngest minds in the flock. You are nothing, worthless, and irredeemable. Except, that for some god-forsaken reason, the lord wants to redeem you. Alas, the connection is made that one can only be made worthy by joining the elect, by adopting the tenets of the doctrine, by giving (sacrificing) your soul—like Jacob his son Isaac—upon the altar of the lord. Only in this way can one become good and noble; can one achieve any purpose in life.

The “unwanted self” may not simply be a result of personal failure in life, as Hoffer would have it. It is also, as any product of parochial upbringing will tell you, the immediate and enduring consequence of indoctrination—be it religious, philosophical, or political; an indoctrination that always terrorizes, especially the young. From images of filthy rags and worthlessness to Cotton Mather's famous depiction of god almighty dangling the sinner over the fire pits of hell, the impressionable young are beaten figuratively—when not literally—to the altar. How better to ensure future offerings than to assassinate the emerging self, and bend the remnants to one's own purposes?

There are parallels between Sunday School, Vacation Bible School, and the Hitler Youth. We must fashion their minds before they are old enough to think; before they have a chance to develop a healthy skepticism; when they still believe in magic. Santa Claus and sky gods are replaced in due course with Televangelists and Supermen. From the churches, to political movements, to the armed forces The breaking down of self and reforming it into the image of a larger “purpose” permeates every society. But make no mistake, the price of admission is high, for the devil wants nothing less than your identity—your soul. This is the nature of identity politics. And this is why our elections, have of late, become contests for the very heart and soul of the nation.

Look about you. The purpose of the national political convention is to bring the nation together, to bind up its wounds, as Lincoln would say. Previously, the parties would intentionally nominate candidates from different sections of the country—given our history of great sectional strife. Not any more. Today it is identity politics that rules supreme. The process must appease not geographical sections but the various identities that the masses carry into the political arena, be it race, gender, abortion or anti-abortion, guns. Where we stand on the issues is not a product of hard reasoning, self-interest, nor even enlightened self-interest, but is our very identity.

Malleable Identity

If you can't believe in yourself, you must believe in something. And that something can be just about anything, for there is a deep-rooted need to believe.

“It is rare for a mass movement to be wholly of one character...The religious movements of the Reformation had a revolutionary aspect which expressed itself in peasant uprisings, and were also nationalist movements. Said Luther: ' in the eyes of the Italians we Germans are merely low Teutonic swine. They exploit us like charlatans and suck the country to the marrow. Wake up Germany!

The religious character of the Bolshevik and Nazi revolutions is generally recognized. The hammer and sickle and swastika are in a class with the cross. The ceremonial of their parades is as the ceremonial of a religious procession. They have articles of faith, saints, martyrs and holy sepulchers. The Bolshevik and Nazi revolutions are also full-blown nationalist movements....” (4) just as the American evangelical religious movement has morphed into the 'moral majority', a wholly-owned subsidiary of the Republican Party.

It is worth adding that Stalin was a refugee from an Orthodox Catholic Seminary, and the swastika was an ancient Christian symbol prominent in the Catholic church attended by a young Adolph Hitler. Indeed, in my youth, there was—and maybe still is—a crypto-fascist periodical published under the banner “The Cross and the Flag”.

“Since all mass movements draw their adherents from the same types of humanity and appeal to the same types of mind, if follows: (a) all mass movements are competitive, and the gain of one in adherents is the loss of all the others; (b) all mass movements are interchangeable. One mass movement readily transforms itself into another. A religious movement may develop into a social revolution or a nationalist movement; a social revolution, into militant nationalism or a religious movement; a nationalist movement into a social revolution or a religious movement.”(5)

And so, to fill the vacuousness left by the ridding of one's self, the True Believer will grasp at any straw, grab hold of any life-boat. This explains the compelling migration of the evangelical Christian to the religious wrong; from the innocuous meeting house to any political arena; from the sacrifice of self to the sacrifice of all. For you don't ask questions, and you don't count the dead, when god's on your side.

An Br'er Putin, he jus' laugh and laugh.

Flush this turd, November 3rd.

_________________

  1. Hoffer, Eric. The True Believer Thoughts on the Nature of Mass Movements. Copyright 1951. Perennial Library, Harper & Row. New York.
  2. Ibid. Page 13
  3. Ibid. Page 21
  4. Ibid. Page 26

Apr 30, 2020

April 30, 2020 You Were Warned, Full-Throated Brown-shirt, Worst Is Yet To Come



You were warned. Adam Schiff stood in the well of the Senate and warned you. He told you that tRUMP knows nothing of the national interest; would learn no lessons from the experience of being impeached other than that once again the rules do not apply to the likes of him. You were warned that with tRUMP it is always about him, only him and no one else.

As he tweets about 'liberating' Michigan, Wisconsin and New Jersey from governors who are proceeding with due caution, tweets that have called armed militia to the state capitals in full-throated brown-shirt tactics in order to re-open an economy closed down by his gross ineptitude. You were warned.

You were warned that he will do anything, sacrifice anyone, to satisfy his own personal ends for, like his hero Adolph, he has confused being the head of state with being the state itself. He thinks he is the nation, and that whatever he sees as good for him, must also be in the national interest. The pandemic and the public be damned.

So the country is being pressured to re-open before any of the states have met the most rudimentary guidelines. All this sacrifice, will be for naught.

In a conversation with our daughter she was lamenting how long it will be before she will be able to leave home and return to work. I told her that with tRUMP one must always prepare for the worst, as he makes a pig's breakfast of everything he touches. The worst is yet to come.

An' Br'er Putin, he jus' laugh and laugh

Flush this turd, November 3rd.

Apr 29, 2020

April 29, 2020: We Were Warned, Grotesque Facade, Common Carnival Barker




You were warned, yes, you were warned, Lawrence O'Donnell reminded us the other night on his MSNBC program. O'Donnell then produced the video of Congressman Adam Schiff as he addressed the Senate during the impeachment proceedings against our Caesar Disgustus. Schiff then warned the body that should, god forbid, a crisis emerge threatening the welfare of the nation, tRUMP could be counted upon only to think of himself. He's done it in the past, is doing it now, and can be relied upon to do so in the future. Schiff, reminded the Senate that for tRUMP the national interest has no meaning; there is only his personal interest. He isn't interested in serving the nation; only serving himself. Importantly, Schiff was making this argument at precisely the moment that the pandemic now upon us was breaking unto our shores.

Of course, the Senate ignored the Congressman, as well as a majority of the people who were then urging the Congress to purge us of this swine.

But as prescient as were the words of the Congressman from California, the fact is that alarm bells were ringing long before he sounded his warning in the well of the Senate. Before his election, biographer David Kay Johnston told his audience and the nation that tRUMP was and is a fraud. Tony Swartz, who actually wrote the book The Making of the Deal launching tRUMP upon the national stage, told audiences well before the election that tRUMP is an ignoramus, and intellectual void and an ethical black hole. Addressing audiences at Oxford University weeks before the election in a speech broadcast on YouTube and elsewhere, Swartz profusely apologized for his role in creating the tRUMPian mythology. In fact, Swartz told anyone caring to hear, tRUMP represents a clear and present danger to the republic and that his election would spell a national, indeed international, disaster.

In case of any doubt, tRUMP's response to hurricane damage in Puerto Rico, as noted in the previous post, should have been a wake up call. Indeed, tRUMP's manifold and manifest inadequacies were readily apparent and duly noted by a certain property maintenance contractor in Athens, Georgia. (1)

In this essay, written a mere six months into this long national nightmare, I pointed out that tRUMP is nearly all facade, and that projecting an outlandish, indeed grotesque, facade creates certain problems when it comes to managing human beings. It explains his thin skin, his knee-jerk need to shoot the messenger rather than listen to the message, his grotesque need to always appear to be in charge, and to override any possible criticisms; his need to blame and his refusal to accept criticism—however constructive-or responsibility for his manifest failures. I pointed out that he will look to others to take the lead, in this case the sycophantic 'boy blunder' son-in-law, and the president of vice Mike Pence as he deals with the pandemic and, as the crisis worsens and he needs to achieve ever greater distance , the governors of the several states. You see, in the end, tRUMP stands Star Trek's Mr. Spock upon his head: The emotional needs of the man outweigh the national interest; the needs of the one outweigh the needs of the many. Disgustus said it all when asked what responsibility he had for the national response to the pandemic when he told the press and the nation “I don't accept any responsibility”. These are the words of a common carnival barker having stolen the emperor's clothes and scepter.

“An' Br'er Putin, he jus' laugh and laugh”

Impeach, convict, remove, imprison.

___________

1. See: http: wandererandshadow.blogspot.com/ August 2, 2017: Hollow to the Core, Ode to Ralph, Only Confusion Now



Apr 28, 2020

April 28, 2020: The Wages of Ignorance, Neanderthal on the Throne, Breathtaking Incompetence



“The wages of ignorance are death”

             ----from “The Quotations of Chairman Joe”


He told us as the infection total reached 15 that it would soon be down to one and then zero. As the pandemic quickly spread and it became obvious that it was quickly about to spiral out of control he, nevertheless, took to the podium at raucous rallies telling the unwashed that it was all a hoax, a Democratic plot to further unseat him; all the while assuring his gullible audiences that all was in hand and the country could continue on its merry way.

It was worse than that. The Washington Post, New York Times and other reliable sources tell us that he was warned several times beginning in early January that a virulent strain of influenza was upon us and that draconian actions would be needed to deal with it. The Secretary of Health and Human Services tried several times to contact him and, after at least two weeks of attempts to get the attention of the ignoramus-in-chief finally, in mid-January, got him on the phone only to be regaled by our Caesar Disgustus about his department's regulation on vaping—a form of nicotine relief for the compulsive smoker, issues having to do with the regulations HHS was apparently applying on flavors of electronic cigarettes. Nothing, it seems, could penetrate the skull of the neanderthal on the throne.

Furthermore, it transpires that tRUMP, ever in the grip of his rage against anything Obama, dismantled the pandemic response structure in the White House, eliminating the staff on the Security Council and DHHS, assigned to monitor and respond to any such crisis. This, of course, was one of the creations of Obama as he dealt with the Ebola and the H1V1 pandemics during his administration. The NSC team was charged with coordinating a national response to any such crisis with the Department of Health and Human Services as well as the Atlanta-based Center for Disease Control, a system that had previously worked well to contain such outbreaks. Disgustus, driven by blind, raging penis envy of course axed the program at first opportunity.

Now, the press informs us, tRUMP is confronted with the first crisis of his 'presidency' not of his own making. Actually it isn't. One may recall that in the first year of this long national nightmare, tRUMP was confronted with massive hurricane damage in Texas and Puerto Rico. The administration responded well enough in Republican Texas, but the lessons learned on the island should have been instructive. Distancing himself from the response, blaming others—particularly local leaders who happen to be Democratic representatives—and then cutting aid altogether when the national spotlight moved on to other scandal, should have served as fair warning of what will come. Now, after nearly four years of damage done to the administrative state, tRUMP no longer has the apparatus at hand to respond to any crisis in any meaningful way. The damage done is taking it's toll.

Now, as the country gets it's first real look at the breathtaking incompetence of a man who clearly cannot manage a respectable lemonade stand the death toll mounts, and with it confidence and respect for our national leadership and institutions.


“An Br'er Putin, he jus' laugh and laugh”


Impeach, convict, remove, imprison.

Mar 21, 2020

March 5, 2020: Gathering Moss, The Snake Pit, Shame Fuels Rage




South Carolina should not be allowed to decide anything. It was here, one may recall, that 'Ol' Two Cows' ambushed John McCain back in the day spreading rumors that he had fathered an illegitimate bi-racial child. It was here that Hillary, despite pillaging Obama eight years later with rhetoric just this side of George Corley Wallace, salvaged her primary campaign against Bernie Sanders. And it is here that, despite his despicable handling of the Clarence Thomas/Anita Hill imbroglio, Joe Biden was somehow seen walking despite all reports that he has long since shed his mortal coil.

The Democratic Party, in full panic, has come to his rescue. Beginning with James Clyburn, the black congressman from South Carolina, and quickly joined by former Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid of Nevada, the party mossbacks began gathering, much like flies gather around a steaming pile of dog shit, the walking cadaver that is Joe Biden.

After summarily dismissing the likes of Senator Kamala Harris, Governor Jay Inslee and over two dozen others, the party aparatchicks fell upon the good-ole-reliable corporate whore from Delaware. Of more than two dozen contestants, the party regulars have finally scraped the bottom of the barrel.

Such is the posture of the current Democratic Party that they would rather put up a cruel joke like Biden than embrace Bernie Sanders. You see, Bernie angers them. Bernie makes them uncomfortable. Bernie makes them ashamed.

For Bernie Sanders is more than a mere scold. He is more than a mere thorn in the side of the modern Democratic Party. Sanders is a measure of the distance between Democratic posturing and Democratic performance. Sanders is a walking, talking, animated reminder of what this party once was and is, therefore, a measure of how far the party has strayed. Sanders is to the Democratic Party what the garden of Eden is to Judaeo-christian theology, or a vacuum to physics: A standard that may perhaps not exist in pure form, but from which we measure all else—and in this case the measurement is our shortcomings. Sanders is, therefore, a standing reminder of Democratic failures, failures for which they should be rightly charged and for which they should be made, like Adam and Eve, to feel ashamed.

But shame fuels rage and the rage directed at Sanders is nothing but the rage of impotence on the part of a party that has neither the substance nor the courage to confront what we all know must be confronted.

As noted in these columns, the fossil fuel industry has mineral rights to five time the amount of carbon which, if burned, will destroy the ecosystem of this planet. I bring this up, when confronting friends and fellow Democrats on social media, and ask them “do you really think Joe Biden will stand up to the fossil fuel industry?” Does one really think that Biden, a corporate whore his entire life, will stand up to the oligarchy now in control of our national destiny? Of course not.

No matter, they rage on, claiming Bernie is unelectable, he being an avowed 'socialist'. They claim, given the results here in South Carolina, that Biden has greater broad based support and that Bernie does not. It is strange how perceptions twist in the wind.

A week ago, the argument went, Bernie was winning in all white states with all white, male votes. This despite the facts that Bernie's support is more female and that Latino voters were with him by large margins. Never mind, chanted the mossbacks, Iowa, New Hampshire and Nevada don't represent the nation. Neither does South Carolina. It never did.

Biden won South Carolina where two thirds of those voting in the Democratic Primary were African Americans despite the fact that blacks comprise a mere 12 percent of the national population. No matter, none of this was pointed out in the celebration that erupted at party headquarters when the results streamed in. Nor was it observed that over half of those voting were over 50 years of age, hardly a mirror to the nation.

The primary in South Carolina, coming as it does on the heels of the contests in the North is meant to be a block on any progressive challenge to the corporate shop at Democratic Party Central. It has served its purpose. South Carolina is where the nation goes to die. Ask Abraham Lincoln.

The mossbacks now swarm about the steaming pile of dog shit if, for no other reason, than to further attract attention and perhaps make the corporate whore from Delaware more substantial and intimidating. They cannot, however, mask the smell.


“An Br'er Putin, he jus' laugh and laugh”

Impeach and Imprison.



Mar 5, 2020

March 4, 2020: End of Days, Obfuscate and Smear, Overboard.




“If the Democratic Party nominates Bernie Sanders, it will be the end of days”, cried James Carville, on MSNBC. Carville, the old reliable Clinton attack dog, had emerged from under their front porch in the wake of Sander's route of the Democratic field in Nevada to sound the alarm.

The panic became palpable when Hillary had voiced scorn for Sanders, telling her audience that “nobody likes Bernie”, and that “he's never accomplished anything”. Rich criticism from a Clinton who, however intelligent, always misses the irony.

But after successive victories in Iowa, New Hampshire and Nevada, and with Sanders staring down the snake pit of the upcoming South Carolina primary, the mossbacks went into full panic mode.


Aided by the bullhorn of the corporate 'left', Chris Matthews of MSNBC's “Hardball” openly voiced concern by telling his audience that the Sander's route in Nevada reminded him of the collapse of the French Army in 1940, drawing parallels between the Sanders' campaign and the Nazi Blitzkrieg. This after expressing terror a few nights earlier that a Sanders victory would mean his being rounded up and shot in Central Park. These tart observations, being as they were on the heels of MSNBC's Chuck Todd equating the “Bernie Bros” on social media with the “brown shirts” revealed the level of panic as the media hosts reached deep into the muck in order to find something pungent enough to smear Sanders. Nothing, it appears, is beyond the pale. Not when corporate dominance is challenged.

Matthews knows better. He is a graduate of Holy Cross College, and has studied History at the University of North Carolina. When he is on his game has been a formidable interrogator, as witness back in 2008 when the McCain campaign put a hapless soul on his program spouting the nonsense about then-candidate Obama and appeasement. Matthews jumped on it quickly demonstrating that his guest had no idea what the term meant and that, in any case, Munich had not historical relevance pertaining to the question at hand. Exactly, no historical relevance. A dozen years later, Matthews has now become his hapless guest spouting false analogies that are only meant to obfuscate and smear.

It is bad enough that the morning programming on one of the few media outlets that even pretends to be socially conscious is continually about the business of “Bernie Bashing”. “Morning Joe”, hosted by former Republican congressman Joe Scarborough features a round table stacked with conservatives, all of whom regularly bash Bernie. Continually telling their audiences that Bernie cannot be elected and that his nomination would surely mean the return of tRUMP in the next election—despite polls continually demonstrating the opposite—their screed has become a full-throated howl as Bernie rose in the polls and threatened to take the nomination.

Matthews is, thankfully, now gone. Summarily dismissed this week from his twenty year long presence on MSNBC, the principle bullhorn of the mossbacks is now retired. The reasons presented were that he had made some untoward remarks to women “back in the day”, and must now walk the plank. The real reason, one suspects, is that Matthews—always a Republican-in-drag—had blown the network's cover; had been too transparent in his bias—a transparency that threatened to alienate the network's audience—an audience that has been led to believe that here the truth matters; that this NBC outlet was no mere corporate shill.

Matthews' sin is that he laid it out for all to see, and he has paid the price for his indiscretions. It won't make much difference, it will simply be less obvious. The network, as in 2016 when they were all-in for Hillary, is promoting the 'moderate'. Throughout the campaign MSNBC has been beating the drum for the 'moderate' Biden or, should he fall short, Bloomberg waiting in the wings in a thinly veiled effort to keep the corporate profits safe by sounding alarm bells over any candidate that would redistribute wealth in this country.

The truth is that MSNBC is not 'liberal' at all. The truth is that there is no 'liberal' media. All media is corporate owned and no media is going to promote any political figure out to challenge the dictatorship of capital.

Matthews has served his paymasters well over the years. He just went overboard.










Feb 19, 2020

February 20, 2020: Scrubbing History, Rot Runs Deep, Fundamental Hygiene




In an essay published in The New York Times, Matthew Connelly warns that the National Archives is currently scrubbing the historical record. It was bad enough, writes Connelly, that the Archives found itself embroiled in a scandal in which photos of the Women's March had been doctored, but the rot seems to have gone much deeper. (1)

Connelly writes that “(T)his is only the latest example of a growing threat to our nation's capacity to protect and learn from history. The press and public have focused on the immediate, obvious problems, like this president's exaggerated claims of executive privilege and national security to conceal information. But less appreciated is the fact that vital information is being deleted or destroyed, so that no one—neither the press and government watchdogs today, nor historians tomorrow—will have a chance to see it.” (2)

Our Caesar Disgustus has long made it a practice, Connelly points out, to tear up notes on meetings and bury transcripts and other records. The recent example of deep-sixing telephone transcripts, the failure to keep White House appointment and telephone logs are notorious examples, as are tearing up notes and records, all violations—as Connelly notes—of the Presidential Records Act. This was another act made into law by Congress in the wake of Watergate to prevent another cover-up. But, like so many other laws passed by Congress to protect us from national scandal and abuses of power (the 1974 act preventing the President from thwarting the will of the Congress as to how money is to be spent, the 1924 act requiring the President to produce his tax returns to duly authorized committees of Congress, both measures passed in wake of scandal) this is just another nuisance brushed aside by our golden swine.

But the rot seeps out of the White House at it makes its way into the sinews of governance. And here the rather nondescript offices of The National Archives—yes The National Archives—come into scrutiny.

Evidently, a document released in 2017 revealed that “Archivists had agreed that officials from Immigration and Customs Enforcement could delete or destroy documents detailing the sexual abuse and death of undocumented immigrants. Tens of thousands of people posted critical comments, and dozens of senators and representatives objected. The National Archives made some changes to the plan, but last month it announced that ICE could start destroying records from Mr. Trump's first year, including detainees' complaints about civil rights violations and shoddy medical care.” (3)


Rest assured there is more. The Interior Department and the Archives “have decided to delete files on endangered species, offshore drilling inspections and the safety of drinking water. The Interior Department even claimed that papers from a case where it mismanaged Native American land and assets—resulting in a multibillion-dollar legal settlement—would be of no interest to future historians (or anyone else). Virtually all the papers of the undersecretary of state for economic growth, energy and environment are also being designated ass 'temporary.

It is hard to know why the government is not holding on to records about antidumping efforts, or the protection of intellectual property, which fall under the new temporary status. It is perhaps easier to understand why the Trump administration wants to delete other records from the under secretary's office, including documents regarding the enforcement (or non-enforcement) of 'health, safety and environmental laws'” (4)

There has been little, if any Congressional oversight. “Not so much as a Congressional hearing”. (5) Indeed, the State Department is planning to cut out archivists altogether, going instead to some computerized algorithm to decide what is “historical” and what isn't.

“Going forward,” writes Connelly, “it is not even planning to turn these records over to the National Archives—a clear violation of the Federal Records Act. (6)

Like everything else tRUMPian, this has been a development some time in the making. The CIA has turned over less than 10 per cent of it's records according to Connelly, and is providing less and less compliance as time goes on; and, given its record, this is deeply troubling.

What's driving this is, in Connelly's view, is both the volume of records and the unwillingness to fund the record keeping. In 1985, for instance, there were 13 million records. Now there are more than 21 billion. But the National Archives, Connelly notes, has few employees now than it had in 1985, and Congress continues to cut it's budget as it has for the last three years.

Indeed, it has become so bad that the National Archives has announced that it will no longer maintain any more presidential libraries.

Every organization rots from the head down. The ship of state is so dysfunctional that even fundamental housekeeping is being abandoned. What was once an imposing Man-of-War has been hollowed out and transformed into a garbage scow. With Caesar Disgustus now firmly at the helm, the rot—at increased speed—is spreading over the deck into every nook and crevice. Yes, the failure to observe elementary hygiene has produced a stench now fouling every port-of call, the nation and every foreign capital. The rot runs deep, threatening the very historical record.


An Br'er Putin, he jus' laugh and laugh


Impeach and Imprison.

_____________

  1. Connelly, Matthew. “Closing the Court of History” The New York Times. Wednesday, February 5, 2020. Page A27.
  2. Ibid
  3. ibid
  4. ibid
  5. ibid
  6. ibid




February 19, 2020: The Federal Purse, To Faithfully Execute, Capricious and Arbitrary



Melissa Quinn, of CBS News, is reporting that the Pentagon official responsible for certifying that Ukraine had complied with federal guidelines, is being removed from his post. (1) According to Quinn, Defense Secretary Mark Esper, acting on instructions from the White House, has requested the resignation of John Rood because, according to a reporter from Bloomberg News the White House had lost confidence in Rood's ability to carry out the president's *(I) agenda.

Translated it means that Rood, who signed off on Ukraine's campaign to fight corruption, had been the one who sanctioned the sending of assistance that our Caesar Disgustus wanted to withhold. By demonstrating that the government in Kiev had complied with Congressional requirements the withholding of such aid would be a violation of the 1974 law prohibiting the president*(I) from sequestering duly appropriated funds and unilaterally deciding how much would be spent and for what purposes. This was a law, passed in the wake of Watergate, that re-asserted the constitutional prerogative of Congress to control the federal purse; a function, which if infringed, would neuter the the power of the legislative branch of government.

Rood had determined that Ukraine had complied with all the requirements laid out by Congress in order to receive the 391 million dollars in assistance and that, therefore, the funds must be dispersed. This caused much consternation as memo's circulated at the highest levels, including among the agency heads and the various inspector general's that withholding these funds violated the law. Accordingly, the action to withhold, until September of last year as the action by our Caesar was about to become public, became the basis of the impeachment probe; a point lost in the ensuing prosecution. Yes, our Caesar Disgustus had violated law, had failed to faithfully execute the law, and had violated his oath of office by failure to do so. Case closed.

But the Senate refused to fulfill it's responsibility and remove the swine, instead granting him carte Blanche to run riot. And this is precisely what he has done in the week since his 'vindication.'. Vindication has brought vindictiveness'; not repentance, nor remorse. In the week since the Senate turned its back on justice he has removed Col. Vindman for his testimony giving lie to the 'perfect' call with President Zelensky, as well as Vindman's brother from his White House post. He has removed ambassador Sondland for his role in describing how 'everyone was in the loop', demonstrating not only that a million dollar contribution to this White House will get you and ambassadorship, but that it won't be enough to protect you if truth be told. Disgustus is hell-bent on scrubbing the White House of anyone who dares speak truth to power.

And, as to demonstrate how he can act capriciously and arbitrarily, Disgustus yesterday commuted the sentences of former Illinois Governor Rod Blagojevich, pardoned junk-bond king Michael Milken and several others. The common denominator seems to be clemency for those prosecuted by James Comey's team at the F.B.I., and convicted of white collar crimes. All this was done in the dead of night, without the customary review procedure. Capricious and arbitrary, doing it not because it is right and just, but because he can.

Moscow Mitch and his cohorts have not chastened the adolescent in the White House. They have simply taught him what he can do. And so, Disgustus, ever the vandal, continues to deface everything within reach.


An' Br'er Putin, he jus' laugh and laugh


Impeach and Imprison


_________________